Roof Repair
Not every drip from a skylight is a leak. In our marine climate, condensation fools a lot of homeowners, and the fix is completely different.
Is water from my skylight condensation or a leak?
Condensation forms on the interior frame and glass as evenly spaced droplets, usually on cool coastal mornings, and it's tied to indoor humidity. A real leak follows storms, often stains the ceiling offset from the unit, and traces to flashing. Wipe the frame and watch when water appears to tell them apart.
Our marine climate sets up the perfect conditions for skylight condensation. Cool, damp mornings meet warm, humid indoor air, and the skylight glass and metal frame are the coldest surface in the room. Moisture in the indoor air condenses on that cold surface exactly the way it beads on a glass of iced tea in summer. It drips, it pools, and it looks for all the world like the roof is leaking.
We get these calls most in the cooler, wetter months, and often from homes with skylights over kitchens and bathrooms where humidity runs high. The homeowner sees water and assumes the worst, but the roof is completely sound. The water was never outside; it came out of the air inside their house.
Condensation has a signature. It appears as small, evenly spaced droplets across the interior glass and along the metal frame, it shows up on cool mornings regardless of whether it rained, and it's worse in humid rooms. Wipe it dry and it comes right back under the same conditions. A leak, by contrast, is tied to rain, tends to concentrate at one spot, and often stains the ceiling offset from the skylight because the water traveled along a rafter before dropping.
The clearest test is timing. Watch the skylight during and after a storm and on a clear but cool, humid morning. If water only appears when it rains, you have a leak. If it appears on dry mornings, you have condensation. If it appears in both, you may have both problems, which does happen.
| Clue | Condensation | Leak |
|---|---|---|
| When it appears | Cool, humid mornings, no rain needed | During and after rain |
| Where the water is | Evenly on glass and frame | One spot, often offset on ceiling |
| Pattern | Fine, even droplets | Streak, drip, or spreading stain |
| Worse in | Kitchens and baths, humid rooms | Wind-driven rain from one direction |
| After wiping dry | Returns under same conditions | Stays dry until next storm |
When the diagnosis is condensation, no amount of roofing work will help, because the roof isn't the problem. The fix is managing indoor humidity and the cold surface. Running exhaust fans in bathrooms and the kitchen, improving ventilation, and lowering indoor humidity all reduce condensation. In some cases upgrading an old single-pane or poorly insulated skylight to a modern insulated glass unit raises the interior surface temperature enough that condensation largely stops.
We also look at whether the light well is contributing. A poorly insulated shaft can turn the whole well into a cold surface. Insulating and properly finishing the well sometimes makes a bigger difference than anything at the glass.
If our testing points to an actual leak, then we're back to the roof, and as with most skylight leaks, the flashing is the usual culprit rather than the glass. We hose-test to isolate which flashing piece failed, then repair it properly with new metal in the correct lapping order and renewed underlayment where needed.
The important thing is not to guess. We've seen homeowners spend money resealing a perfectly good roof because they misread condensation as a leak, and we've seen the reverse, where someone bought a dehumidifier while a real flashing leak quietly rotted the deck. A proper diagnosis saves both money and the roof.
Sometimes a skylight has an old unit that condenses heavily and aged flashing that leaks, and the homeowner can't tell where one problem ends and the other begins. In those cases replacing the unit and re-flashing at the same time solves both in one visit. The new insulated glass stops the condensation and the fresh flashing stops the leak.
When we inspect a problem skylight, we test for both rather than assuming. It's the only way to be sure the homeowner isn't left with half the problem still dripping after the work is done.
An Encinitas homeowner called about a skylight over their bathroom that dripped every few mornings. They'd assumed a leak and were bracing for a roof repair. But the drips didn't line up with rain, and they were always worst after morning showers.
When we inspected, the glass and frame showed a fine, even film of droplets, the classic condensation pattern, and the flashing hose-tested completely dry. The skylight was an older single-pane unit right over a shower, the worst possible combination in our marine climate.
We replaced it with an insulated low-E unit and recommended running the bath fan longer after showers. The morning drips stopped. No roof repair was needed at all, and the homeowner was relieved to learn the roof had never been the problem.
Ask us during a free inspection. Straight answers, no pressure.